Riesling Reviews

International Wine Report, Owen Bargreen, August 2017

Impossible to resist

2014 Riesling

91 points: This fantastic Spring Mountain Riesling from Smith-Madrone opens with pretty aromas of white peach, lychee and lime followed by crushed stones and hints of white floral, which all take shape beautifully in the glass. On the palate this fresh and inviting Riesling is well balanced with a wonderful mix of fruit and acidity. Overall, this is a dry style of Riesling, but there is a lovely hint of residual sugar, making this impossible to resist. 

http://internationalwinereport.com/latest-reports/reports-usa/217-california/spring-mountain-district/6422-2014-smith-madrone-riesling-napa-valley

Lilianacabana blog, Linda Coco, January 18, 2018

Phenomenal Riesling

2014 Riesling

From the first sniff and sip, I was left nearly speechless. One word burst forth: KALEIDOSCOPE! In my mind’s eye, I saw multiple points of lights in dazzling array, reflecting in sparkling symmetry. Layer upon layer of myriad shapes and colors coalesced in prism perfection, evolving in an ever changing, ever enchanting montage. This Riesling is just that. From its lush bouquet of honeysuckle, lemon, orange blossom, stone fruit, pear, mint and a hint of petrol to its layered palate of apricot, peach and lychee (stone fruit trifecta!) and grapefruit, tangerine & lime (citrus trifecta!), there is no end to the vibrant scents & flavors of this immensely complex wine! There is just the faintest whisper of sweetness, barely discernible, thank the heavens above! The strong backbone of minerality is laced with pleasing salinity. Crisp & defined like the jagged points of a kaleidoscope pattern, each sip shaves the palate clean. Yet juxtaposed on that trademark acidity is a lingering silky finish that made me slap my hand on the counter & sigh. This is a phenomenal Riesling for Riesling haters! This is a phenomenal Riesling for Riesling lovers! I have reformed. No longer a Riesling rebel but now a Riesling raver, I hope you take my rah-rah review seriously. And not with a grain of salt, please, but rather a tiny bit of residual sugar on top. Trust me, an encounter with this wine will color your world in brilliant kaleidoscope patterns.

https://lilianacabana.wordpress.com/2018/01/18/a-riesling-rave-by-a-riesling-rebel/

The Drunken Cyclist, Jeff Kralik, December 14, 2017

Gangbusters. Outstanding.

2014 Riesling

OK, that’s it. This is the fourth or fifth American Riesling that I have had in recent weeks that proves my theory—American Riesling producers have caught up to the Old World. Perhaps more than any variety, makers of Riesling in this country seem to get it: it is all about the acidity. This Smith-Madrone (one of the most under-rated Napa producers) has great citrus, melon, and a touch of petrol (ever-so-slight) followed by lip-smacking tartness and a weighty  mouthfeel. Gangbusters. Outstanding. 91-93 Points.

https://thedrunkencyclist.com/2017/12/14/continuing-to-embrace-napa-with-smith-madrone-and-addendum/

Maker's Table, Meg Houston Maker, November 5, 2017

A 'spirited white' for Thanksgiving

2014 Riesling

A "Spirited White," great with lighter meats and vegetarian options, but can also cut through butter and cream…Yes, there is a little Riesling grown in Napa Valley—or I should say, “still grown;” this one derives from 42-year-old vines. Its robe is pale yellow and it offers typical aromas of wax and wet street mingling with lemon oil, thyme, and rubbed sage. The body has good substance, with a mix of tree fruit, citrus and tropical fruit (guava and passion fruit), and the finish is long and succulent.

http://makerstable.com/2017/08/25/2014-smith-madrone-riesling-spring-mountain-district-napa-valley/

WineSplashing, Rick Fillmore, October 2

94 points

2014 Riesling

This beautiful Riesling is all estate grown in the Spring Mountain District using 42 year old vines. It is 100% varietal and fermented in stainless steel tanks. Aromas of honeysuckle, orange blossom, lychee, and citrus fruits. Medium bodied across the palate with a bright acidity. Ripe flavors of white peach, Asian Pear, citrus, and a hint of minerality at the finish. Pair with Asian foods, fresh salads, baked chicken or ham, and seafood. 94 Points. 

https://winesplashing.com/2017/10/02/smith-madrone-napa-valley-wines/

Samantha Stowell, ILikeThisGrape, October 6, 2017

A fine solace

2014 Riesling

Now for those of you in denial of summer’s end, this Riesling is a fine solace for your woes. The honeysuckle and lemon peel aromas will certainly remind you of warmer weather. The slight, yet distinctive petrol aromas, orange blossom notes and smooth mouthfeel will finish bone-dry. It seems to usher you right into the drier, savory months of autumn. Similar to this varietal’s old world versions, Smith-Madrone grows their Riesling along the steep mountain slopes that assist beautifully in their ripening process and crisp, refreshing notes. Whether paired with crab or seasoned pork loin with root vegetables, surely this wine is truly fit to consume no matter what time of year.

http://www.ilikethisgrape.com/of-riesling-and-cabernet-and-pumpkin-spice/?utm_source=Hubspot%2FWebsite&utm_campaign=7c013c8ad5-RSS_EMAIL_CAMPAIGN&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_dcb45d178f-7c013c8ad5-229126765

WineForNormalPeople, Elizabeth Schneider, July 19, 2017

Lively, tasty Riesling

2014 Riesling

A pale straw color, this wine smells like lime and limeade! Jasmine flower, gardenia and other white florals with a stony, earthy quality fill out the aroma. The taste is a slightly toned down version of the smell with high acidity but a round, soft texture. A dry Riesling, the flavor has an herbaceous, stony quality to balance the citrus notes. Amazing that you can grow such a lively, tasty Riesling in Napa. It’s a feat many try but at which few succeed. 

Made from their estate grown fruit high atop Spring Mountain, the brothers Smith, who own and operate the winery, are focused and land-oriented. Vines have thrived on the hillsides of their 200 acre property for over 100 years, and not much has changed. Smith Madrone dry farms their estate (they don’t use irrigation/watering), they study terroir – especially slope and soil type – to match the grape to the site, and the result is distinctive wines that have a sense of place.

https://winefornormalpeople.com/lovely-napa-wines-but-the-question-remains-are-they-worth-the-money-given-whats-out-there/

Philip Kuo, WineGuys, September 23, 2017

Magical...and an incredible value

2014 Riesling

Having tasted a number of super sweet Rieslings from California, you could say that we haven't really been too enthralled about it and usually shift towards German Rieslings, but this magical one from Smith Madrone really is a wonderful expression of what Californian Riesling can and should be. Notes of green apples, white peach, apricot, kiwi, lime, slight saline, citrus peel, orange blossom and crushed rock. Really clean mouthfeel, well structured, bright acidity and huge backbone of minerality. Don't sleep on this gem, mountain grown Riesling is where the grape actually thrives (on the slopes). Incredible value wine. 

https://www.instagram.com/p/BZXdESOH8W2/

SoifKnows, Stephen McConnell, September 18, 2017

Churning brilliance

2014 Riesling

Salty honey, melon and mineral explode with acidic fireworks straight at you.  Viscous banana and sharp fresh paper placate and shred the nostrils at once, vibrant and alive, churning brilliance.

All your Riesling dreams and goals are coming to life in this one, boys and girls.  This is one not often trotted out in trendy recent who’s-who lists of California Riesling, but this grandfather from Napa GETS IT.  Where your hipster groupings run somewhere between "interesting" and :odd," this Spring Mountain stalwart cranks out the goodness it has for DECADES.

In the mouth, lilokoi coats the tongue, sweet and peppery, lavish and razor-sharp, curious curls of petrol greasy syrup fall around, elevating and propping up the eviscerating acid.  Fat and ripe EXACTLY where it needs to be, but chubbiness surrounded by chilling minerality makes for a textbook Riesling.

https://soifknows.com/2017/09/18/napa-riesling-goals/

Forbes, Cathy Huyghe, September 1, 2017

Experience and creative skin in the game

2014 Riesling

Why (why?) do we not drink more Riesling from California? From Napa, even? Yes, I know (I know...) that Napa wins with its Cabernet Sauvignon and Chardonnay, and even with its Sauvignon Blanc. But, if you're a college football fan, that's a little like saying Alabama, USC or Ohio State are going to win the NCAA title this year, so what's the use in all the other teams even playing? Come on. You know that there's more to it than that, that it's the chutzpah that makes it interesting, and that there are winemakers in Napa with a lot more experience and creative skin in the game. Stu and Charles Smith have been working these vines -- these specific Riesling vines in a specific location on the slopes of Spring Mountain -- for more than 42 years now. They get what needs to be got from it, and put it all in the bottle.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/cathyhuyghe/2017/09/01/5-white-wines-to-celebrate-the-last-hurrah-of-summer-each-with-a-twist/#427c6c241d4d

The American Wine Society Journal, Fall 2017, Ellen Landis

High-spirited spot-on Riesling

2014 Riesling

Fragrant citrus blossom, slate and hints of earth show brilliantly on the nose with this high-spirited spot-on Riesling. White peach, Meyer lemon, crushed herbs, honeysuckle and a solid thread of minerality simply dazzle the palate. Impeccable balance and verve carry through the long, lime-accented finish.

Decanter Magazine, September 2017, Oz Clarke

Zesty acidity

2014 Riesling

Lemon, honey, cinnamon and peppermint dominate on the nose, completed by a juicy, sweet grapefruit palate. There’s sufficient zesty acidity to make it refreshing, backed by typical Riesling characters that last on the finish.

Grape-Experiences, Cyndy Rynning, August 3, 2017

Long and luscious

2014 Riesling

Absolutely delicious, this bright and lively 100% Riesling prompted several “Wows!” and more than a few “Riesling from Napa?” remarks when I poured tastes for friends. All of us were delighted and rightly so. Fresh aromas of lemon, yellow flowers, orange peel, stone fruit, and minerality burst from the glass. Clean and gracious, notes of juicy citrus and minerality, zesty acidity and a round mouthfeel were dominant with each sip. The finish on this crisp, dry Riesling? Long and luscious.

http://www.grape-experiences.com/2017/08/fascinating-smith-madrone-the-people-the-place-the-wines/

Vinography, Alder Yarrow, July 29, 2017

Excellent acidity

2012 Riesling

Light blonde in the glass, this wine smells of petrol and citrus peel. In the mouth, tangerine peel and citrus pith mix with crackling crushed stone minerality. Excellent acidity. While this wine may have had a hint of sweetness when first released, it is headed towards savoriness. It has entered its second phase of maturation, leaving its fruity youth behind and heading towards something more sophisticated.

http://www.vinography.com/archives/2017/07/vinography_unboxed_week_of_jul_11.html

NapaFoodandVine, Amber Burke, July 28, 2017

Perfect balance of fruit and acidity

2014 Riesling

Our number one choice and our favorite is a dry Riesling from Smith-Madrone. It is the perfect balance of fruit and high acidity. The nose is of peach blossoms and lime. The wine is so smooth on the palate and it has an incredibly long finish. The pairings of food and wine combinations with this bottle are endless.

http://napafoodandvine.com/2017/07/28/demystifying-riesling-wines/

Vinography, Alder Yarrow, July 22, 2017

Regal on the palate, delicious as always

2014 Riesling

Napa's best Riesling was also on offer this week, in the form of the annual bottling from Smith-Madrone on Spring Mountain. This vintage is particularly charming….Palest gold in the glass, this wine smells of citrus pith, mandarin peel, and a touch of diesel. In the mouth, faintly sweet flavors of Asian pear, mandarin juice and pink grapefruit have a gorgeously bright aspect thanks to excellent acidity. The wine finishes quite long and regal on the palate. Delicious, as always.

 

 

http://www.vinography.com/archives/2017/07/vinography_unboxed_week_of_jul_10.html

Rockinred blog, Michelle Williams, July 17, 2017

Truly fantastic wine

2014 Riesling

Pronounced aromas of crushed stone, petrol, white stone fruit, citrus and jasmine; dry racy palate with medium+ mouthwatering acidity, elegant with medium body, great minerality/crushed stone on the palate, long finish; this wine is truly fantastic, makes a great summer pairing with sushi, seafood, salads, poultry, shellfish, frittata, pizza, etc;.

https://rockinredblog.com/2017/07/17/6-refreshing-white-wines-to-pair-with-summer/

The Tasting Panel Magazine, July 2017, Meg Houston Maker

Big personality with a tiny footprint

2014 Riesling

This waxy, stone-scented mélange mingles citrus, guava and passion fruit and offers a succulent finish. 

http://digital.copcomm.com/i/844641-july-2017/26

International Wine Review, Don Winkler, June 21, 2017

90 points

2014 Riesling

The 2014 Riesling from Spring Mountain is light straw in color and highly aromatic with a floral nose, stone fruit and up front tropical fruitiness. Medium-weight with good density, it is easy drinking and offers considerable pleasure.

http://i-winereview.com/blog/index.php/2017/06/30/smith-madrone-current-releases-from-spring-mountain-district-napa-valley/

Cuvee Corner blog, Bill Eyer, June 20, 2017

Classic Riesling characteristics

2014 Riesling

The vines are grown on Eastern exposures, honoring the international steep slope tradition. The age of the vines is 42 years, very mature, giving outstanding depth and complexity, in my opinion, not achievable by vines in their early leaf years. The aromas delivered the classic Riesling characteristics. A good amount of petrol, a bit carbonated, stone fruits like apricot, lime rind, wet stone, and white peach flesh. The taste was a bit off-dry, though the acidity was crisp, the body was medium and the tannins were moderate, well-integrated. On the palate, kiwi slices, grated lime rind, wet stone minerality, stone fruits, apricot, peach, and nectarine. The finish was long and persistent. This wine is recommended, my score, 90 points.

https://cuveecorner.blogspot.com/2017/06/wines-of-week-smith-madrone-uncorked.html

Dan Berger's Vintage Experiences, June 13, 2017

Superb

2014 Riesling

The aroma of orange blossoms and a faint trace of earthy/TDN give this superb wine an off-dry impression, as does the entry because the wine is so rich, and has a trace of sugar. But the wine is relatively dry since the acid level is so perfectly suited for the intensity. Sensational with Thai cuisine.

https://www.vintageexperiences.com/2017/06/13/tasting-notes-19/

WineReviewOnline, Robert Whitley, May 2, 2017

Exquisite example of impeccable balance

2014 Riesling

The 2014 dry Riesling from Stu and Charlie Smith is an exquisite example of impeccable balance combined with intense aromas and a final result that is greater than the sum of its parts. The nose offers an alluring minerality that is impossible to miss but hardly overwhelming. With zesty green fruits, yellow citrus and pear notes, the flavors are remarkably complex. The palate is smooth, with a long, clean finish. Drink now or cellar for several years. It will only get better with a bit more time.

http://winereviewonline.com/wine_search.cfm

WineReviewOnline, June 13, 2017, by Rich Cook

94 points

2014 Riesling

94 points: Smith-Madrone sticks with their Riesling planting because they love what it does, and you should love it as well.  Pay no mind to the California Riesling haters -- this is the real deal, delivering fresh pear, stonefruit, white flowers and mixed citrus in a crisp, dry, refreshing package that will make you wonder why every California winery isn't making and promoting Riesling.  Those in the know can tell you that dry Riesling goes with just about anything at the table -- and that it ages well.  Cheers to the Smith brothers for ignoring alleged market trends and continuing to make this stellar wine.

http://winereviewonline.com/wine_search.cfm

Good Vitis blog, Aaron Menenberg, June 9, 2017

Perfectly balanced acid and weight

2014 Riesling

A reticent nose but a compelling palate with streaky flint and slate, dandelion and orange zest held together by perfectly balanced acid and weight. It just needs more time in the cellar to bring that nose to bear and fully develop.

Riesling is a wine geek’s wine. It’ reflects terroir like no other, and since it does well in many, many climates and is therefore grown all around the world, we can experience a lot of different terroir through the lens of one grape. Further, it ranges from bone dry to very sweet, which makes it even more diverse a grape to explore, especially with food (wine pairing: one of the most passionate interests of a wine geek). These factors combine to make riesling exponentially interesting to people who like to pay close attention to their wine, which makes riesling’s commercial struggles all the more frustrating because it puts an artificial ceiling the amount of production by providing a lot of financial disincentive for wineries to produce the grape, let alone put a lot of effort into it.

It is fitting that Smith-Madrone was the inspiration of the tasting as its owner and winemaker, Stu Smith, is an outspoken proponent of the grape who makes it despite the difficulty he has selling it because he believes so fundamentally in its importance and worth as a varietal that speaks to the very best of what wine can be. In addition to myself and Isaac, our tasting panel included other riesling lovers who we felt would understand why we were doing the tasting and enjoy the experience: Washington Post wine writer Dave McIntyre, wine consultant Alison Smith Marriot, and two serious oenophiles/drinking buddies of mine. And then we had a special guest…Stu Smith of Smith-Madrone Winery!

Stu was able to swing by about fifteen wines into the tasting and catch up to the group by the end. It was a real pleasure to have Stu and Julie Ann join us in an effort to further appreciation of the grape Stu seems to feel the most passionate about. The wines were tasted blind in a randomized order and, knowing that his wine was the impetus for the tasting, the unveiling of his wine as a consensus top-3 pick came as what I would imagine was at least a little relief, though who were any of us, really, to pass judgment on the wine of a Napa icon? More than anything, I (and I imagine the rest of the group) am just thankful Stu continues to prioritize a high quality riesling given the lowly demand for it.

https://goodvitis.com/2017/06/09/a-grand-american-riesling-tasting/

Wine Enthusiast, July 2017, Virginie Boone

94 points

2014 Riesling

Entirely estate grown from dry-farmed grapes, this white sparkles with waxy apricot and pear flavors and crisp, underlying mineral stoniness. Dry, with refreshing acidity, it doesn’t skimp on mouthfeel, delivering a viscosity that’s invitingly complex and lingering.

http://www.winemag.com/buying-guide/smith-madrone-2014-estate-bottled-riesling-napa-valley

---

<< PREVIOUS - Page 11 of 15 - NEXT >>